At
10:57 AM 7/13/2006, you wrote:
Hello, David.
I
came across your article, Crazy Music, during a search, and wanted to send you
a brief email to offer an alternative point of view. Since you wrote it 15 years
ago or more, perhaps your views have changed, but since your article is still
posted for public consumption, I wanted to respond.
While agreeing with you that
Pride is a major trap in any kind of public ministry, be it preaching, singing
or playing, you make a grave over-generalization
in stereo-typing contemporary music as bad (or, as you say, without a conscience)
and traditional music as good, or a return to sanity. You do an injustice to
all those contemporary artists and worship leaders who write quality music and
meaningful lyrics with a clear conscience before God. You also gravely overestimate
the righteousness of the older writers, many (probably all) of whom struggled
with temptation, sin and pride, as men are prone to.
I could categorize every
old piece of worship music as pompous and stuffy, but would also do an injustice
to those writers who penned vehicles of worship which still speak today. Those
same writers also penned pieces of fluff, poorly written music with cliché
lyrics, which were never heard again. Many of those writers wrote hundreds,
if not thousands of hymns and pieces of music, most of which never saw the light
of day, or made it past the first church service or concert. I agree with you
that there is a machine in the Contemporary Christian Music industry ( and also
in the traditional Christian Music Industry, I might add) that is out for self-gain
and glorification, especially for profit, but it is not all encompassing. Don’t
close your mind to powerful, passionate, God honouring and glorifying worship
music because of the few that don’t. As well, since you too are a sinner,
don’t under-estimate the power of God and His Holy Spirit to use sinners
such as you, me, and the worship artist who is misdirected in their worship
leading to speak to someone the words that they need to hear, or to enable someone
to express their heart to God. The beauty of the faith we share is the Cross,
and its power to forgive and redeem.
Blessings
John
Roeper
Worship Pastor
Maranatha Church
72 Orchard Drive
Belleville, ON
K8P 2K7
613-962-2062 x17
********************************
From:
David Heesen [mailto:heesendr@beloit.edu]
Sent:
Thursday, July 13, 2006 12:47 PM
To:
John Roeper
Subject:
Re: Crazy Music
Dear
Brother John:
Amen! I agree with much of what you say. I am glad you read my article and hope
you got something
out of it. Rather than retract my article, may I, with your permission, add
your comments at the end as a "response from a reader." That will help create
a more balanced treatment of this controversial subject. Sorry, I can't really
argue with what you say, nor am I willing to "recant" of my rant. I didn't mean
to stereotyping contemporary music as bad and traditional music as good. We
should judge these things on a song-by-song basis.
Meanwhile, are you familiar with Steve Camp's excellent website (http://a1m.org/)?
Steve Camp is a contemporary musician. Of particular pertinence is his "107
Theses."
God bless you.
David H.
**************************
July 13, 2006
Greetings again!
Thank you for responding so quickly. You are welcome to use my comments if you wish. I have not seen Steve Camp’s website, although I am familiar with him. Thank you for the suggestion, I will check it out. It sounds intriguing. Thanks again.
Blessings!
John Roeper
Worship Pastor
Maranatha Church
72 Orchard Drive
Belleville, ON
K8P 2K7
613-962-2062 x17